Treasure Island:

This is definitely the best toy store in the area! Located in the heart of Riverdale, Treasure Island has a wide variety of quality toys and books. There are toys at the front of the store that your kids can play with in order to distract your children while you shop. The staff are friendly, knowledgable and helpful. Possibly the best feature is the free gift wrapping that they offer. This is perfect, as you can then purchase the birthday gift en route to the party! 4 stars